11/12sp compatibility Q

leitch

leitch

Feelin' a bit rrranty
moorey said:
It’s an outrageous price for a chainring...and neither pushys or MTBD specify the drop stop A option, only 12sp. This is destined for the FW thread either way.
Click to expand...
Agreed it's ridic but the 12sp Shimano rings that might not do the job properly are still $85 so...

Other options include finding a second hand 170mm GXP DM crankset for which there are loads of chainrings available but that doesn't meet your Shimano requirement.
 
moorey

moorey

call me Mia
leitch said:
Agreed it's ridic but the 12sp Shimano rings that might not do the job properly are still $85 so...

Other options include finding a second hand 170mm GXP DM crankset for which there are loads of chainrings available but that doesn't meet your Shimano requirement.
Click to expand...
But the 12sp rings don't definitly do the job. Internet says both, and @The Duckmeister says an 11sp chain runs a bit rough on them.
A bloody chain is $80 anyway. Between cranks, chainring and chain, thats nearly $400, and no confirmation it all runs perfect on 11sp derailleur and cassette.
 
leitch

leitch

Feelin' a bit rrranty
moorey said:
But the 12sp rings don't definitly do the job. Internet says both, and @The Duckmeister says an 11sp chain runs a bit rough on them.
A bloody chain is $80 anyway. Between cranks, chainring and chain, thats nearly $400, and no confirmation it all runs perfect on 11sp derailleur and cassette.
Click to expand...
Yeah sorry that was my point, if it's $85 for a Shimano ring that might not work (whether that's because it's a bit rough, or the chain bounces off easily, or it wears out too quickly) then $150 for WTC, while objectively extortionate, is at least guaranteed to work with 11sp der/chain/cassette

Buy a new WTC ring and @DMan's cranks to cut out some of the surplus. Or that OneUp thing^
 
bear the bear

bear the bear

Is a real bear
leitch said:
Yeah sorry that was my point, if it's $85 for a Shimano ring that might not work (whether that's because it's a bit rough, or the chain bounces off easily, or it wears out too quickly) then $150 for WTC, while objectively extortionate, is at least guaranteed to work with 11sp der/chain/cassette

Buy a new WTC ring and @DMan's cranks to cut out some of the surplus. Or that OneUp thing^
Click to expand...
$110 for the Oneup system from MTBDirect
 
moorey

moorey

call me Mia
leitch said:
Yeah sorry that was my point, if it's $85 for a Shimano ring that might not work (whether that's because it's a bit rough, or the chain bounces off easily, or it wears out too quickly) then $150 for WTC, while objectively extortionate, is at least guaranteed to work with 11sp der/chain/cassette

Buy a new WTC ring and @DMan's cranks to cut out some of the surplus. Or that OneUp thing^
Click to expand...
Waiting for @Nerf Herder to check if the Burgtec DM runs 11sp chain.
 
moorey

moorey

call me Mia
The oneup is DM, but with a bolt on ring. Might present the same potential frame clearance as a regular chain ring. Otherwise, could be a good option if Bergtec isn't 11sp.
 
moorey

moorey

call me Mia
Petero said:
Interestingly they show both 12sp and 9-12sp as options of each chainring size..

EDIT: From Oneup site the other option is - "Compatibility: All Switch Carriers; 9, 10, 11 and 12 Speed SRAM Chains (not compatible with 12 Speed XTR Chains) " - https://int.oneupcomponents.com/collections/switch/products/switch-replacement-rings
Click to expand...
It only mentions 9-12 SRAM chains....which tells me that the shimano 12 is different (not just XTR)
Maybe I've just over read, and confused myself to the point of choice paralysis as usual :(
Cheers man.

Edit. I'll be running an 11sp chain though.....so that should work regardless. Think i'll try this if the Burgtec DM doesn't work.
 
bear the bear

bear the bear

Is a real bear
moorey said:
It only mentions 9-12 SRAM chains....which tells me that the shimano 12 is different (not just XTR)
Maybe I've just over read, and confused myself to the point of choice paralysis as usual :(
Cheers man.

Edit. I'll be running an 11sp chain though.....so that should work regardless. Think i'll try this if the Burgtec DM doesn't work.
Click to expand...
You need this version
int.oneupcomponents.com

OneUp Components Switch Chainring System - 11 & 12 speed Chainrings

A quick-change direct mount chainring system Switch was developed to reduce the cost of replacement chainrings, increase compatibility with new offsets and to make the process of changing your chainring much faster and simpler. Cheaper Replacement Cost - Replacement rings are a fraction of the...
int.oneupcomponents.com int.oneupcomponents.com
 
moorey

moorey

call me Mia
You don't get a choice of offset on the shimano (not applicable). Should't that be important, given they don't specify non boost/boost/super boost?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top