I bought a pair of Extreme RR goretex last year (for road) and overall they were really good, kept me warm and dry (in a Tassie winter). Fit well and were comfortable. Things I didn't like, they were super hard to get on and off (they did break in a bit though)...and... they stunk, liek really really stank. Not sure if it was something I road through, my toxic sweat or the cat peed on them...or they jsut stank. Washed them, scrubbed them, deoderised them a bunch. Nothing worked, couldn't keep them in the house. GF made me toss them they were that bad.
NW sizing is different to most, about 1 full size down if looking at Eu sizes
SO I bought some Mavic Ksrium thermo pro goretex, which are really good, feel a bit smaller than the NW's . But warm and cosy and so far don't stink.
To go with that I bought some Sidi Frost Goretex for mtbing, didn't like these so much and even though they are the same size as my other Sidi, they are a bit big and I coudl never get to fit right. (size 45 if anyone want to buy them)
So then I bought some Mavic Crossmax thermo Pro goretex, cause well I like the ksriums, and these are also really good. (If i do them up wrong, a bit of the tounge digs in, but otherwise they are perfect, road them on an over 2 hour wet ride the other day, warm and dry and comfortable. Also like the ksrium really easy to get in/out of.
So if anyone want some sidi frost (45) going cheap, hit me up. (or go find some NW (44) at the launny alndfill)