You'd have to think that scarring would be normal, as that part of the piston is outside the seals and prone to all the dirt entering through the bore from the outside.
Agree. It actually strikes we as a bit of a design flaw to allow the piston to be that unprotected. I would think that there should be a rubber boot or something given its a spot were debris and dirt can get into, but there is no easy way to clean it. Below are some terrible pictures I tried to take on my phone.
Key things I noticed:
1. So much crap on the lever
2. There was a LOT of crap behind the outer seal. It was obviously doing it's job to keep it out from going any further but given how much build up there was, I suspect this would contribute to the sticking issue.
3. The main scarring was on the bit fat bit, with only very minor scarring on the bits past the outer seal
4. That C-clip is a c##t to get out and a c##t to get in. My pliers where about 3mm too short to do it easily