Done the same thing a while back, though I am nearly sure I didn't tighten the 2 bolts.
The spindle is fine, just stripped about 50% of the crank arm splines. My cranks stayed on though with the plastic tensioner is still in place.
Had to do some work on eldest kid's fork and only realised at school leaving time this morning that I'd somehow stuffed the re-install and the headset isn't turning properly Let him take the Paradox so he could get to school on time, received a message from him when he got there with 'this is a...
www.rotorburn.com