Big JD
Wheel size expert
yes they are efficient, fast and cut down my commute by around 10 minutes (usually 45 on a MTB SS) - I get that. They are great for long rides on the road into the hills and along the beach - if you are into that sort of thing. I just dont see the benefits of a drop bar road bike for commuting out weigh the disadvantages.
Drops - I never ride in the drops - always on the hoods and in that position the effectiveness of the brakes(standard road type) is poor. Drops give you multiple positions but few where the brakes are in good position.
Brakes - rim brakes suck - well mine do - and in an emergency you just skid those skinny slick tyres
Tyres - so bloody skinny and puncture so easily especially after rain and they are certainly not strong enough for the odd gutter drops or jumps and pot holes.
Position - suited for aero positioning on the bike with longer stems the norm. Also road bikes suited for sitting and spinning where alot of commuting requires quick changes in position.
Toe Over Lap - WTF - I had no idea this existed and what a major hassle - esp on a SS.............. this is reason for me alone
After commuting on mountain bikes for years and a road bike for a few months, I personally feel so much safer on a MTB with strong wheels, great brakes, more upright position and big tyres with grip. I commute in Melbourne and a MTB also give me the opportunity to hit the trails on the way home.
Anyone else feel this way or am I just not getting it?
Drops - I never ride in the drops - always on the hoods and in that position the effectiveness of the brakes(standard road type) is poor. Drops give you multiple positions but few where the brakes are in good position.
Brakes - rim brakes suck - well mine do - and in an emergency you just skid those skinny slick tyres
Tyres - so bloody skinny and puncture so easily especially after rain and they are certainly not strong enough for the odd gutter drops or jumps and pot holes.
Position - suited for aero positioning on the bike with longer stems the norm. Also road bikes suited for sitting and spinning where alot of commuting requires quick changes in position.
Toe Over Lap - WTF - I had no idea this existed and what a major hassle - esp on a SS.............. this is reason for me alone
After commuting on mountain bikes for years and a road bike for a few months, I personally feel so much safer on a MTB with strong wheels, great brakes, more upright position and big tyres with grip. I commute in Melbourne and a MTB also give me the opportunity to hit the trails on the way home.
Anyone else feel this way or am I just not getting it?
Last edited: