I was out riding yesterday and I got myself a sidewall puncture from a loose rock the size of a golf ball - see above picture. The tyre didn't go flat but it did leak to the point of it being too low to ride properly. I got out my pump and pumped it up, but I found that it hadn't/wasn't sealing properly with the sealant inside. Not knowing what to do I washed the area with some water to try and remove the grit and then covered the hole with my finger (not sure why I did that but I figured it couldn't hurt). It seemed to seal and hold pressure when I pumped some more air into it.
Later I thought I'd put a bit more air in it because it was still a little low. When I was getting to about 25psi (my usual pressure) the hole re-popped and air came out again. I put my finger over it once more and this fixed it. It still had plenty of pressure so I rode home.
Today I pumped the tyre up properly to 25psi but I'm nervous that the puncture is still weak and as soon as I get a big hit or have something brush against it, it will re-pop. I have a spare tube and pump, so a flat won't be catastrophic, but I don't have any sealant fluid (yet) and so I don't want to take the tyre off to repair it with a patch if I don't have to.
Does anyone have any similar experiences or advice?