Mr Pants I agree Jubes should be a very significant proof of concept of how suburban councils can provide facilities for MTB in fairly urban locations. I also agree that with public support Jubes would form the basis to convince the council to expand the facility and as an example to other councils of what can be achieved.
The reality is that to fulfill the role described above, Jubes should be a blueprint of sustainable trail building techniques, an exemplar for other trail builders and authorities to look at, learn from and show how to achieve sustainable outcomes whilst building trails.
Unfortunately Jubes falls short of this, the criticisms I have made - not sustainable, no armouring of the track, lack of drainage, no trees retained or mature vegetation - are unfortunately valid and I think they undermine the role that Jubes could play with the local and other councils. The reality is the track built at Warrimoo is a much better example of what can be achieved as far as sustainable trail building techniques.
Criticism and disapointment should not be interpreted as a whinge. My comments were limited to the build; I left the "less than amazing" nature of the track alone - however I am concerned this will limit the ongoing patronage and potentially create the situation where Council views it as a 'white elephant' that relative to the level of investment doesn't get used much nor have any impact in reducing illegal trail building in the area.