Hmm I've always been a bit down on spearfishing.
I'm in the main a technical scuba diver these days, do most of my diving round the Fleireu Peninsula and Mt Gambier, but I used to dive every weekend in Sydney.
Whether it was being missed by about a foot by a spear shot at me and my buddy off Bare Island bommy (He swore it was an accident, but then how do you accidentally shoot at divers?)...
Whether it's seeing them in Jervis and Shelly beach marine reserves...
Whether it's seeing a guy get out with a string of blue grouper (Where's the sport in shooting fish that swim up to you?)...
Or just guys with way more fish than they could possibly eat.
Admittedly I'm not above grabbing a pocket full of scallops if I see them down there, and I'm sure there are responsible spearos out there taking account of size, bag limit and looking out for reductions in catch, but experience has taught me that a disproportionate number are idiots and to stay well away.
Anyway I guess we're all having fun underwater and enjoying the amazing stuff that's down there. So long as we all look after it.
Yes Arete, unfortunately there are a few irresponsible Spearo's around which don't do the vast majority of other "responsible" ones any justice.
Spearfishing is quite unique in the fact that you can just
select the fish you intend to take and eat. Unlike line fishing where you catch anything, and everything that'll take your hook. Line fishing is size and species indiscriminate. Some of the unwanted "line caught" fish thrown back often later die due to their injuries, or even infection when the slimy protective coating is removed during handling.
I, and everyone I dive with, are always safe and responsible. Spearfishing
is looked down upon. I myself when returning to my car with my catch feel somewhat scrutinized by others around. However it is quite rewarding when those curious about the sport actually approach you and ask you a few questions.
Just like MTB, and other sports and activities, we need to be responsible so that we can continue to enjoy the things we love to do.
Cheers, Shorerider.